Truth or Dare is a great game to play as long as you know what you’re getting into – not having any secret crushes or other private information you’d prefer kept close helps with the truth, and being just a little bit drunk helps with the dares. But even for the most prepared individuals, things can go disastrously wrong – and this r/AskReddit thread gathered some of the worst truth or dare stories out there.
1. Terrible truth or dare for the friend, but a very sweet meet-cute story for the girlfriend (story from billbapapa)
Uni – all drunk. Friend dared his girlfriend to make out with another chick. She did. Awesome. She likes it. They flirt / talk a lot during drinking. End of night comes, they go “home” (back to her dorm room) together. My friend / the boyfriend isn’t invited. Weeks later, girlfriend actually leaves him to be with the other girl.
2. To be fair, Soul Calibur is super fun, so this worked out for everyone (story from ghost0427)
Myself included, the party was 3 guys and 3 girls. When the game started getting steamier and we had taken most of our clothes off, a guy asked one of the girls, and she chose dare.
“I dare you, to make out with me in the bedroom, along with [the other two girls]”
They went with him. The other guy and I spent the next hour playing Soul Calibur in our underwear.
3. This is why I always go “truth” – that way, I only have to deal with the EMOTIONAL equivalent of drinking pee (story from MyAnimalsBite)
Young, like 11 or 12, playing truth or dare with my friends outside at my house.
One friend dares me to piss in the bird bath which was in plain sight of where my parents and neighbors could see. I do it, he thinks its funny.
Next time it comes around to him he chooses dare. Other friend dares him to drink the water in the bird bath
That went wrong on him quick.
4. This story probably amounted to thousands of dollars worth of therapy (story from djchuckles)
Middle school. Buddy was dared to go into closet and kiss this girl. Long time goes by so we check on them. He was so nervous he pissed himself and they were trying to clean up the mess with the clothes that were hanging up.
5. Honestly, it’s the boyfriend’s fault for asking a question where there’s a 50% chance that the answer will be “not you” (story from tFalk)
Girl picked Truth, her BF ask who was the best fuck she ever had. She named his brother. She was drunk and told the truth, but he was super pissed. We got to watch the whole thing. Turns out it was before she was dating him, but he was still upset.
6. ALWAYS GO TRUTH. Truth never leads to having a broken ankle in the nude in the middle of winter. (story from Dan_christ)
Back in college we were pregaming at my friends apartment playing truth or dare jenga. I pulled a brick that said to do a lap around the outside of the building naked. Easy enough, but it was the middle of winter so I slipped and fell on some ice and ended up breaking my ankle.
7. Probably a bad idea to gang up on someone and pressure them into kissing everyone. (story from lemondropPOP)
When I was in 10th grade I was invited to a small party of just my girl friends and just 1 guy. All these girls had a crush on the one guy and told me that they wanted to play truth or dare and my job was to make sure he was to kiss them or whatever at all times. Well he caught on and would only say truth so they asked him out of all us girls who he was willing to fuck and he said me. Turns out he was gay and said me because he knew I wasnt trying to be rapey. I was very unpopular that night after he left.
8. Aw, Molly, c’mon. (story from Bucket_O_Beef)
Steve dared Molly to kiss me. I gave him $20 to do it. Molly ran out of the room crying.
9. Always lock the door. (story from Pipster27)
Friend’s living room. 9pm. 40min in. everybody drunk or half drunk.
I started the fire by daring a girl to go topless and dance.
10min later Shit got real and cant exactly remember what was the exact dare or who invented it but like 2 seconds after dare was starting my friend’s mom opened the door just in time to see 2 topless dudes, 1 topless girl, 1 empty bottle of vodka, just opened bottle of wine and one girl about to lick another girl’s ass.
We were all 16
10. Sometimes a story goes so wrong, that it’s so right. (story from tdasnowman)
Got dared to run around the block naked, it wasn’t NYE’s but might have been close. I’m running I took the half block option because well I’m chubby fuck and therefore less running. So I do the main street portion of the run few honks all is well. The back stretch runs along a park on one side church on the other. There’s a guy running from the park and at first I think awww, poor little white guy running from the big black naked guy what a fucked up evening for him. Then I glanced over at the church and see fire in the windows and realize ohh he’s running from the fire he started and give chase. My friends waiting outside our apartment complex with a robe and a shot see random stranger run by, then me in full on naked chase mode yelling call the cops and the fire department. So I gained a bit on that guy, but like a block down I realized we just called the cops and the fire department the fire department is an alley away from us and I’m naked black guy running through the neighborhood I need some clothes. Turn back and make it to my friends and a robe just in time for the cops to roll up, Fire department showed came over a few minutes later. Fire was an xmas tree in the park, my drunk ass saw the reflection in the church windows. Cops had also got a call about streakers but didn’t mention it till they left.
BONUS! Here’s a tale of truth-or-dare that SEEMINGLY went well…until a bit of time allowed the guy to re-think what had actually happened. (story from Maverick_OP)
One of the few times I was invited to a girl’s birthday party, with only two other guys and maybe seven girls, the girls all decided to play truth or dare/spin the bottle mash-up. It also began to dawn on me that the birthday girl had a crush on me and this was all a set up. I had no idea how to kiss and I pulled one of the guys that I was friends with aside and asked him to help me get out of this. He told me he’d help me out but I’d owe him big time. We went back in and sat down. After several truths and small dares from the other girls the birthday girl spun the bottle and it landed on me. She dared me to kiss her for five seconds. As we began to lean in a horrid smell hit all our nostrils. My friend set off a stink bomb in the trash can and forced us all to leave the room. We all laughed it off and I decided it was late enough to leave. The girl had to throw out the trash can but I got out of having my first kiss with a cute girl I had a crush on.
TL;DR: My friend set off a stink bomb because I didn’t want to kiss a girl.